Some people think that charity organizations should only offer help to people of their own country. But others believe that these organizations should give aid to people in need no matter where they live.

Practice this IELTS Writing Task 2 question on IELTSX. Some people think that charity organizations should only offer help to people of their own country. But others believe that these organizations should give aid to people in need no matter where they live.

Charity organizations offering help only to people of their own country versus giving aid regardless of location - IELTS Writing Task 2

You should spend about 40 minutes on this task.

Discuss both views and give your own opinion.

Write at least 250 words.

A student's answer to this task, and the feedback on it

Written by an IELTSX user under exam conditions and published unedited and anonymously. Band 8 · 317 words.

In recent years, the role and responsibility of charitable organizations have become a subject of intense debate. While some argue that charities should prioritize the needs of their own citizens, others maintain that aid should be distributed globally, regardless of geographical boundaries. In my opinion, while local issues must be addressed, humanity’s interconnectedness necessitates a global approach to humanitarian relief.

Those who believe charity should be confined to national borders often cite the concept of "charity begins at home." The primary argument is that a nation has a fundamental duty to its own people first. Every country faces its own internal struggles, such as homelessness, poverty, or inadequate healthcare. Proponents of this view argue that it is illogical to provide funds to foreign nations while domestic citizens suffer from preventable hardship. Furthermore, it is often easier for local organizations to understand the cultural context and specific needs of their own people, leading to more efficient and accountable aid distribution.

On the other hand, the argument for global aid is rooted in the belief that human suffering is universal and should not be limited by borders. Many crises, such as natural disasters, pandemics, or extreme famine, are beyond the capacity of a single nation to handle alone. In these instances, international assistance is a moral imperative. Furthermore, global aid can foster international cooperation and stability. By addressing poverty and instability in developing nations, countries can help prevent the root causes of issues like mass migration or international conflict, which ultimately benefits the global community as a whole.

In conclusion, I believe that while it is vital for organizations to support their own citizens, it is shortsighted to limit aid solely to one’s own country. A balanced approach is ideal: charities should remain attentive to domestic needs while simultaneously contributing to a global safety net. By working together, we can address human suffering effectively, regardless of where it occurs.

Examiner feedback

This is an exceptional essay that demonstrates a high level of proficiency in all four assessment criteria. The writer presents a balanced view, strong logical flow, and highly accurate language, making the argument compelling and easy to follow.

Task Response - 8

- All parts of the prompt are addressed with a well-developed, clear position. - The arguments provided for both sides are relevant and extended with insightful reasoning. - The student presents a mature and nuanced conclusion that supports the overall argument.

Coherence & Cohesion - 8

- The essay is organized into clear, logical paragraphs. - Cohesive devices such as "on the other hand," "furthermore," and "in conclusion" are used effectively to guide the reader. - The progression of ideas flows smoothly from the introduction to the balanced conclusion.

Lexical Resource - 8

- The vocabulary is sophisticated and contextually appropriate (e.g., "humanity’s interconnectedness," "moral imperative," "shortsighted"). - Collocations are natural and precise. - There is an absence of errors in word formation or spelling.

Grammatical Range & Accuracy - 8

- The essay employs a wide range of complex sentence structures with high accuracy. - Punctuation is used correctly throughout. - There are essentially no grammatical errors, demonstrating consistent control.

Related prompts

Start Practice